Research projects

Project CEMAPRE internal

TitleOn Generalizations of Sprague-Grundy Theory
ParticipantsAlda Carvalho (Principal Investigator)
Summary"Combinatorial impartial games are the subject of the well-known Sprague-Grundy Theory [1,2,3]. To
simplify, considering games in finite digraphs with no cycles and no carry-on moves, where pieces do
not conflict, the theory is easily applied: one begins by identifying the terminal nodes
(G-value=0), and then, using a backward algorithm, applies the Mex Rule until obtaining the G-values
of all nodes.

If the digraph, although finite and without carry-on moves, has cycles, the Smith-Sprague-Grundy
Theory applies [4]. One begins by identifying the terminal nodes (G-value=0), and then, using a
backward algorithm, applies the Mex Rule together with reversibility until it is no longer possible
to do more. At that point, the unfilled nodes are in a cyclic zone and should be marked with
infinity(C), where C is a set of reachable nimbers (C may be empty).

If the digraph, although finite and without cycles, admits carry-on moves, the LNS-Sprague-Grundy
Theory applies [5]. In a graph with carry-on moves, there are green nodes that should not be
associated with any Grundy value. Whenever a piece is moved to one of these nodes by a player, the
opponent has to play that piece in the next move. One begins by identifying the terminal nodes
(G-value=0), and then, using a backward algorithm, applies the Mex Rule to I union P (immediate
nimbers and protected nimbers) until obtaining the G-values of all nodes that are not green.

The aim of this project consists of understanding what the most comprehensive generalization of the
Sprague-Grundy Theory is. In particular, is it possible to achieve a generalization that
simultaneously encompasses all the cases mentioned in the previous paragraphs?

[1] Bouton, C. «Nim, a game with a complete mathematical theory», The Annals of Mathematics, 3(2),
35-39, Princeton, 1902.

[2] Grundy, P. «Mathematics and games», Eureka, 2, 6-8, Cambridge University, 1939.

[3] Sprague, R. «Über mathematische Kampfspiele», Tohoku Mathematical Journal, 41, 438-444,
Tohoku University, 1935.

[4] Smith, C. «Graphs and composite games», Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series A, 1, 51-81,
1966.

[5] Larsson, U., Nowakowski, R., Santos, C. «Impartial games with entailing moves», Integers: The
Electronic Journal of Combinatorial Number Theory, 21B, #A17, 2021.
"